Table of Contents
Who Was Belle Gunness?
Belle Gunness, originally born Brynhild Paulsdatter Strseth on November 11, 1859, in Selbu, Norway, is infamously known for her involvement in a series of suspicious deaths and insurance frauds after immigrating to the United States in 1881. Following her arrival, a troubling pattern emerged, characterized by mysterious fires and an alarming number of fatalities, many resulting in significant insurance payouts. In a disturbing twist, Gunness utilized lovelorn advertisements to attract wealthy men to her farm, after which they seemingly vanished. Authorities later unearthed the remains of over 40 victims on her property; however, Belle herself disappeared without a trace.
Early Life
Belle Gunness grew up in a modest household as the daughter of a stonemason. Motivated by a desire for prosperity, she immigrated to the U.S. in search of better opportunities. Unfortunately, her pursuit of wealth soon led her down a perilous path, marked by escalating criminal activities and insurance fraud.
Life of Crime
Gunness’s criminal exploits began shortly after her marriage to Mads Albert Sorenson in 1884. Not long after their wedding, the couple’s store and home mysteriously burned to the ground, resulting in a substantial insurance payout. The situation became increasingly sinister when Sorenson died of heart failure on the same day that his two life insurance policies overlapped. Despite his family’s insistence on an investigation, no charges were filed, leading to speculation about Gunness’s involvement.
Tragedy struck the couple further with the suspicious deaths of their two children, who Gunness allegedly poisoned in infancy to collect insurance money. The pattern of unexplained deaths continued, with the demise of her new husband, Peter Gunness, and the untimely passing of her adopted daughter, Jennie, whose body was later discovered on Belle’s property.
Gunness then turned to the personal ads in local newspapers, seeking wealthy suitors. Tragically, these men, including John Moo, Henry Gurholdt, Olaf Svenherud, Ole B. Budsburg, and Andrew Hegelein, arrived at her farm with cash and subsequently disappeared without a trace. In 1908, just as suspicions began to mount—particularly from Hegelein’s brother—Gunness’s farmhouse caught fire. Among the ashes, workmen discovered four skeletons; three were identified as her foster children, while the fourth, believed to be Gunness, was notably missing its skull.
Following this fire, authorities unearthed numerous shallow graves around the farm, ultimately exhuming the remains of more than 40 men and children, cementing Gunness’s legacy as one of America’s most notorious female serial killers.
Mysterious Disappearance of Belle Gunness
On May 22, 1908, Ray Lamphere, who had been employed by Belle Gunness, was arrested on charges of murder and arson. He was ultimately convicted of arson but acquitted of the murder charges. While serving his sentence, Lamphere revealed critical information regarding Gunness and her nefarious activities. Notably, he disclosed that the body found in the ruins of her home was not Gunness’s.
Investigations unveiled that Gunness had meticulously orchestrated her disappearance, including the deliberate burning of her house. Following this incident, she withdrew a substantial sum of money from her bank accounts and vanished without a trace. Despite extensive searches, Belle Gunness was never located, and her fate remains shrouded in mystery, with no confirmation of her death.